Overview
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million over a Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from a phone's gallery for posting. The regulator found the feature was enabled by default and accessed users' photos, videos and related metadata without free and informed consent. SecurityWeek reported the same penalty as roughly $887 million.
What the Garante Found
- Feature: "Gallery suggestions" in the Facebook Android app, available since 2023.
- Default on: The feature was active without an explicit opt-in.
- Bundled permission: A single app-wide permission covered several functions with different purposes, and a general notice did not clearly say gallery suggestions were also being turned on.
- Legal basis: Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. Reading data stored on a device requires free and informed consent, whether or not the data is transmitted or harm results.
Penalty and Orders
The fine is about 0.47% of Meta's global revenue. The Garante weighed roughly 20 million Android users in Italy, the duration of the breach (ongoing for users who have not updated or who already granted permission), a 2019 prior decision and limited cooperation. Changes Meta made after the complaint were counted in its favor but judged late and limited to updated apps.
Meta must:
- Report within 30 days on the work it has begun.
- Within 60 days, request consent through a separate, specific prompt explaining the feature, the gallery access and how to disable it.
- Within 60 days, keep the feature off by default, including for users who previously granted permission.
- Report within 90 days on measures taken.
If the 60-day deadline is missed, the feature cannot be enabled for anyone without valid consent.
Background and Jurisdiction
The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti. Meta argued Ireland's regulator should lead the case. The Garante rejected that, noting ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism, so national authorities can act on their own.
Meta's Response
Meta plans to appeal and calls the fine "disproportionate." It says the feature works only after users grant device permission, which they can change in settings at any time.
The investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI models, which Meta denies. The Garante may separately look at a newer cloud-processing feature launched this year.
What This Means for Organizations
- Permission design: Broad OS-level permissions do not equal consent for each purpose. Separate prompts per feature are the safer pattern.
- Defaults: Features that read local device data should be off until the user opts in.
- Regulatory path: ePrivacy-based cases can be pursued by any national authority, bypassing the GDPR one-stop-shop route.
- MDM and BYOD: Review which social apps on managed Android devices hold gallery or media permissions, and restrict them where business data may be present.
